Puppy Myth-Busting: 'Cry It Out', Tired Puppies, and Common Myths

The internet is an amazing resource, but it is also flooded with outdated, harmful, and downright bizarre puppy advice. If you are a new owner in Solihull, you've likely received conflicting advice from well-meaning relatives, strangers at the park, and random online forums.

Let's debunk the top 5 biggest puppy myths so you can train your dog with confidence, science, and kindness!

Myth 1: "Let Your Puppy Cry It Out in the Crate"

THE TRUTH: The "cry it out" method comes from outdated human sleep-training advice. In puppies, prolonged distress crying releases high levels of cortisol (the stress hormone) in their developing brain. Leaving an 8-week-old puppy alone to panic in the dark teaches them that their cries for safety will be ignored, worsening separation anxiety. Always comfort a distressed pup!

Myth 2: "A Tired Puppy is a Good Puppy"

THE TRUTH: Over-exercising or over-stimulating a puppy to "tire them out" is one of the biggest causes of evening biting, hyperactive zoomies, and destruction! Puppies need 18-20 hours of sleep per day. An overtired puppy is like an overtired toddler—they lose all impulse control. Mental enrichment (sniffing, Lickimats) tires a dog far safer and calmer than endless physical running.

Myth 3: "Puppies Must Meet Every Single Dog They See"

THE TRUTH: Allowing your puppy to greet every dog on lead creates an over-excited greeter who pulls, barks, and whines whenever another dog comes into view. Aim for neutrality—teaching your puppy to ignore other dogs and focus on you is the true goal of socialisation.

Myth 4: "You Must Be the 'Pack Leader' / Alpha"

THE TRUTH: Dominance theory in domestic dogs was thoroughly debunked decades ago by modern veterinary behaviourists. Your puppy isn't trying to "dominate" you when they pull on the lead, jump up, or go through a doorway first—they are simply uneducated or excited! Training built on partnership and positive reinforcement builds lifelong trust.

Myth 5: "Saying 'NO!' is Enough Training"

THE TRUTH: Shouting "NO!" tells a puppy what NOT to do, but it fails to teach them what they SHOULD do instead. If your puppy jumps up and you yell "NO!", they still have high energy and no clear instruction. Teach them "Sit for fuss" instead—give them an alternative positive behavior!

Are you looking for puppy training In Solihull?

If so, book a free call and lets chat.